November 12, 2026
It has been about a year since Montvale Mayor Mike Ghassali posted on Instagram that a Trader Joe's could be coming to the Chestnut Ridge Shopping Center. In that time the project has been through a Planning Board hearing, received final site plan approval, and won a Bergen County road permit. The Fresh Market that held the space has closed.
By the estimate of the attorney The Record interviewed for its August 30 update, the construction timeline starts when the last permit is issued. As of that report, several permits were still outstanding.
Here is how the paperwork stands, in order:
And here is what The Record said was still open as of August 30:
| Permit | Issued by | Status in the August 30 report |
|---|---|---|
| Soil movement permit | Montvale Planning Board | Still needed |
| Building permits for electrical, plumbing, fire safety and new construction | Montvale building department | Comes after the soil movement permit |
| Possible demolition permits for part of the existing center | Local | Possibly needed, according to the land use attorney |
| Flood Hazard Individual Permit for parking lot changes and a construction access drive | New Jersey Department of Environmental Protection | Pending; the state asked Regency for more information |
The order matters. According to Jeanne Fondacaro, a Montvale construction and zoning employee quoted by The Record, the soil movement permit comes from the Planning Board first, and only then does the project go to the building department. The board's fall schedule had nothing on it for the shopping center. Its September 15 meeting was cancelled, and the Planning Board page shows the October 6 and October 20 agendas focused on a redevelopment-area matter covering Block 3102 and Block 3201.
Thomas Garlick is a partner at Murphy, Schiller & Wilkes, a firm focused on commercial real estate and construction. He told The Record that demolition and construction on a project this size typically take 18 to 24 months, and that cold winter weather can slow the work. He also said the clock starts on the date the final permits are issued.
That changes the math for anyone in town hoping to shop there soon. Here's a hypothetical: if every remaining permit were issued the week this post comes out, in mid-November 2026, Garlick's range would have demolition and construction running until somewhere between May 2028 and November 2028. That window covers the building work only and isn't an opening date. Every month the permits take beyond that pushes both ends of the range back by a month. Since the work would start in winter, the slower end of his estimate is a real possibility.
A March approval, a June county permit and a state agency asking for more detail are all ordinary steps for a project like this. As of the last public update, though, the final permits that start Garlick's clock hadn't been issued.
The plans themselves say a lot about what the store will be.
Planning documents show the Trader Joe's at 13,562 square feet. The Food Industry Association puts the average grocery store at over 42,000 square feet, so the Montvale store would be about a third of that size. That fits the former Fresh Market space it would replace. Regency doesn't have to build a large new grocery building. It plans to renovate an existing one, as NJBIZ reported in January.
Parking follows the same pattern. The plans assign 117 spaces to the Trader Joe's, out of 409 proposed for the whole plaza, so the grocery store would have a bit under 30 percent of the lot. The remaining 292 spaces would serve the existing tenants and the restaurants planned for a new building.
One more detail: Trader Joe's representatives haven't said publicly where in Montvale they plan to open. The Record's location for the store comes from public records and officials' statements, which point to the Chestnut Ridge plaza.
The Trader Joe's gets the headlines, but the plan also includes a new 7,600-square-foot building for three restaurants. The names Mayor Ghassali posted are Shake Shack, honeygrow, which serves build-your-own stir-fries, and CAVA, a Mediterranean lunch spot. NJBIZ described the new building as going on a pad site near Drop Fitness.
The building is new construction, and the state permit covers the access drive needed to build the new retail buildings. So the restaurants depend on the same pending approvals as the grocery store. Garlick gave his 18-to-24-month estimate for a project of this scope, which includes the new building as well as the grocery space. Building a new pad is a different job from renovating an existing store, and nothing published says the restaurants will open before, after or alongside the Trader Joe's.
The shopping center isn't the only project on this part of Montvale.
Just up the road, the Planning Board approved a use permit for a Tim Hortons at 128 Chestnut Ridge Road at its April 21 meeting, The Bergen County Girl reported in May. Unlike the Regency project, nothing in that report describes demolition, a new building or a state permit.
On the corporate side of town, Pascack Press reported in September that Stack Street Coffee & Tea will occupy the entire 75,000-square-foot building at 100 Philips Parkway for roasting, production and distribution. It's a different kind of project from the plaza, but it's another reuse of an existing Montvale building, this time for coffee production.
The Chestnut Ridge Shopping Center is the one project on this list that needs demolition, a new building, a soil movement permit and a state permit, and that's why its timeline runs in years.
The next public sign of progress will most likely be a soil movement permit for the Chestnut Ridge Shopping Center on a Planning Board agenda. That's the step Fondacaro described as coming before the building department. The borough posts agendas on its Planning Board page ahead of each meeting. After that, the steps to watch are a state decision on the Flood Hazard Individual Permit and the issuance of building permits. Once the last of those permits is issued, the 18-to-24-month construction estimate begins.
If you own a home near Chestnut Ridge Road and want to know how a project like this shows up in local sale prices before and after it opens, I'm glad to go through it with you. Contact Chris Crawford to request your free market consultation, and I'll show you what nearby sales have done while the plaza has been in the approval process.
I work with sincerity and have built my company's foundation on the strong values of integrity, efficiency, client advocacy, and results. I have many years of experience with project management before diving into the real estate industry, and I go the extra mile to deliver customer satisfaction. Begin your journey into real estate with me today.